About the Role
The Manager of Donor Relations & Stewardship is the museum’s strategic leader for donor engagement, stewardship, recognition, and membership experience. This position develops and implements a comprehensive donor relations program to strengthen donor retention, deepen engagement, and foster long-term philanthropic relationships. The role ensures donors, members, and supporters receive thoughtful, personalized, and mission-centered engagement, overseeing stewardship strategy, recognition programs, membership engagement, benefit fulfillment, impact reporting, and donor communications. This position also leads fundraising event committees and cultivates a modest donor pool with an annual revenue goal, supervising the Membership Engagement Coordinator and partnering with fundraising staff.
Responsibilities
- Develop and lead a comprehensive donor relations and stewardship strategy.
- Establish stewardship standards, recognition policies, and engagement practices.
- Cultivate, solicit, and maintain a pool of 30-50 donors.
- Create and maintain stewardship matrices for various donor types.
- Ensure consistent, personalized, and timely stewardship experiences.
- Oversee all donor recognition programs.
- Develop and implement donor impact reporting initiatives.
- Coordinate stewardship reporting for major, endowment, planned giving, and campaign donors.
- Partner with fundraising staff to create customized stewardship plans for leadership donors.
- Provide strategic oversight of the museum’s membership program.
- Supervise the Membership Engagement Coordinator.
- Partner to establish clear pathways from membership to philanthropic giving.
- Oversee member and donor engagement programs.
- Collaborate with Events staff to create meaningful donor, member, and volunteer committee experiences.
- Oversee stewardship, communications, recognition, and benefit fulfillment for donor circles, giving societies, and volunteer support groups.
- Partner on engagement strategies for various donor communities.
- Collaborate with Marketing, Communications, Curatorial, Learning & Creativity, and Advancement colleagues to develop donor-centered communications.
- Ensure donor communications reflect the museum’s mission, values, and commitment to exceptional hospitality.
- Promote a museum-wide culture of stewardship and donor appreciation.
- Develop stewardship metrics and regularly assess donor engagement and retention outcomes.
- Manage budgets associated with stewardship, recognition, and membership engagement initiatives.
- Serve as a strategic thought partner to Advancement leadership.
- Perform other duties as assigned.
Requirements
- Bachelor’s degree and minimum of four (4) years of successful professional fundraising OR 8+ years of comparable experience.
- Experience soliciting, securing, and stewarding corporate gifts/sponsorships preferred.
- Strong interpersonal skills.
- Excellent written, verbal, and listening skills.
- Ability to make effective presentations to individuals and groups.
- Proven ability to work effectively with a diverse population of donors and prospects, board members, staff, and community leaders.
- Demonstrated success in working both independently and as a team member to create and implement fundraising strategies at the major gifts level.
- Strong sense of organization, planning, and time management.
- Proficiency in Microsoft Office products.
- Must be able to work some evenings and weekends.
- Travel required.
- Must have a valid passport.
- Knowledge of donor software programs, preferably Blackbaud products.
Skills
- Interpersonal skills
- Written communication
- Verbal communication
- Listening skills
- Presentation skills
- Independent work
- Teamwork
- Organization
- Planning
- Time management
- Microsoft Office proficiency
- Donor software knowledge
Location
- Buffalo, NY 14222
Work Type
- Full-time
Experience Level
- 4+ years of professional fundraising experience
- 8+ years of comparable experience
Education Level
- Bachelor's degree
Salary/Compensations
- $63,000.00 - $68,000.00 per year
